Motorcycle accidents are already complicated when it comes to pursuing compensation for injuries. When a pre-existing condition is involved, these cases become even more challenging to handle, particularly in North Carolina. Pre-existing injuries can be a focal point in any personal injury claim, and how they are addressed can dramatically influence the outcome of a motorcycle accident claim. Understanding how North Carolina law treats pre-existing injuries in motorcycle accident cases can help victims navigate this complex landscape and obtain the compensation they deserve.
Pre-existing injuries are physical conditions or ailments that a person had before an accident occurred. These injuries may be completely unrelated to the motorcycle accident, or they could be conditions that were aggravated or worsened by the accident. Either way, they can significantly impact a personal injury claim because insurance companies often use them as a reason to reduce or deny compensation. This is especially relevant in a state like North Carolina, where the law is already strict regarding personal injury claims due to the contributory negligence rule. This rule can bar recovery if the injured party is found even partially at fault for the accident. Phillips & McCrea, PLLC provides dedicated legal support for motorcycle accident cases, guiding clients through the process to ensure they receive the compensation they deserve.
How North Carolina Law Treats Pre-Existing Injuries in Motorcycle Accident Claims
In North Carolina, the law allows individuals who have pre-existing injuries to seek compensation if the accident worsened or aggravated the condition. However, the burden of proof falls on the injured party to demonstrate that the motorcycle accident caused a significant worsening of their pre-existing injury. North Carolina follows what is known as the “eggshell plaintiff” doctrine. This legal principle means that defendants must take the injured person as they are. Even if the injured person is more susceptible to harm because of their pre-existing condition, the defendant is still responsible for any exacerbation of that condition caused by the accident.
However, this principle does not automatically guarantee a favorable outcome for victims with pre-existing conditions. Insurance companies will often attempt to argue that the injuries sustained in the motorcycle accident are unrelated to the crash or that the accident did not significantly worsen the pre-existing condition. This makes proving the exacerbation of an injury vital to any motorcycle accident claim involving pre-existing injuries. The injured party must provide medical evidence that illustrates the difference between the condition before and after the accident to establish that the motorcycle accident had a direct impact on the severity of their injury.
Attorney Attorney Attorney
Michael Phillips
Marcel McCrea
Natalie Andruczyk
Challenges Faced When Proving Aggravation of Pre-Existing Injuries
When a motorcycle accident aggravates a pre-existing injury, proving the extent of the aggravation can be challenging. The insurance company or the defense may argue that the symptoms were already present before the accident or that the current condition is the result of the natural progression of the pre-existing condition rather than the accident. Therefore, the most important element of any case involving pre-existing injuries is medical evidence. Without comprehensive medical records and testimony, it can be difficult to establish that the motorcycle accident caused the pre-existing condition to worsen.
It is crucial for the injured person to obtain detailed medical records documenting their condition before the accident. This includes medical records, doctor’s notes, diagnostic tests, and treatment history related to the pre-existing injury. After the motorcycle accident, additional medical evaluations and diagnostic tests will be necessary to show how the injury has worsened due to the accident. In some cases, testimony may be required to explain the extent of the aggravation and how it directly relates to the motorcycle accident. Medical specialists can testify as to the differences in the condition before and after the accident, offering opinions on how the accident contributed to the worsening of the pre-existing condition. Without this kind of detailed evidence, the injured party may struggle to prove that the accident significantly worsened their pre-existing injury, which could result in reduced or denied compensation.
Michael was a pleasure to work with. He made sure all of my questions were answered in a timely manner. His compassion to help allowed me to receive excellence throughout my experience, i would highly recommend his expertise” - Anonymous Philips and McCrea Law firm provided excellent service to entire family and friends. There have been several situations that I/family /friends have depended on their legal service’s. On each occasion they have been professional, knowledgeable and dependable. Providing excellent representation and guidance under stressful situations. I would highly recommend their legal service." - Denise Simply great legal service. They were professional, easy to work with and thorough. I have been very pleased with their service and would highly recommend them to my friends and colleagues as exceptional Charlotte attorneys." - Logan Abrams 
North Carolina’s Contributory Negligence Rule
In motorcycle accident claims involving pre-existing injuries, North Carolina’s contributory negligence rule can present additional challenges. Under this rule, if the injured party is found to be even one percent at fault for the accident, they may be barred from recovering any compensation. This is a strict standard compared to most states, which follow a comparative negligence system that allows injured parties to recover partial compensation even if they are partially at fault for the accident.
In cases involving pre-existing injuries, the defense may argue that the injured party’s condition contributed to the accident or to the severity of their injuries. For instance, they may claim that the pre-existing condition made the motorcyclist less capable of avoiding the accident, thereby contributing to their own injuries. The injured party must be prepared to counter these arguments with strong evidence showing that the accident was entirely the fault of the other party. Otherwise, they risk having their claim completely denied under North Carolina’s contributory negligence law.
The Importance of Legal Representation in Pre-Existing Injury Cases
Given the complexities of motorcycle accident claims involving pre-existing injuries in North Carolina, it is essential for injured parties to seek legal representation from an experienced attorney. Pre-existing injury cases require detailed knowledge of both medical and legal principles, and the process of gathering evidence to prove that the accident worsened a pre-existing injury can be complicated. An attorney can help the injured party obtain the necessary medical evidence, consult with specialists, and build a compelling case to demonstrate that the motorcycle accident aggravated the pre-existing injury.
Moreover, an attorney can help the injured party navigate the contributory negligence rule and counter any claims that the pre-existing injury contributed to the accident or the severity of the injuries. Legal representation is particularly important in cases where the insurance company is attempting to minimize the claim by pointing to the pre-existing injury as a reason to reduce compensation. Without legal representation, the injured party may struggle to present their case effectively and may be vulnerable to tactics used by insurance companies to avoid paying full compensation.
Choosing a Personal Injury Attorney Personal Injury Case Case TimelineRelated Videos
How Pre-Existing Injuries Can Impact the Amount of Compensation
Pre-existing injuries can have a significant impact on the amount of compensation a person receives after a motorcycle accident. Compensation in personal injury claims is meant to cover medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages related to the accident. However, when a pre-existing injury is involved, the amount of compensation may be reduced if it can be shown that the injury was not entirely caused by the accident.
In North Carolina, the injured party is only entitled to compensation for the extent of the injury that was caused by the motorcycle accident. This means that if the accident aggravated a pre-existing injury, the injured party can only recover compensation for the aggravation of that injury, not for the original injury itself. For example, if a motorcyclist had a back injury before the accident, and the accident worsened that injury, they would only be entitled to compensation for the additional pain, suffering, and medical expenses caused by the aggravation of the injury, not for the underlying condition.
To maximize compensation, it is critical to provide clear and convincing evidence showing how the accident worsened the pre-existing condition. This often requires the assistance of medical professionals who can provide opinions and detailed reports on the extent of the aggravation. Without this evidence, it can be difficult to obtain full compensation for the damages caused by the motorcycle accident.
Seeking Medical Attention Immediately After the Accident
If you have a pre-existing injury and are involved in a motorcycle accident, seeking medical attention immediately after the accident is essential. Even if the pre-existing injury does not seem to be significantly worsened at first, symptoms may develop or worsen over time. Delaying medical treatment can harm your claim because the insurance company may argue that your condition was not aggravated by the accident, or that the worsening of your injury was due to a lack of timely medical care.
By seeking medical attention right away, you can create a record of the injury and its progression, which can serve as important evidence in your motorcycle accident claim. In addition to documenting the injury, following all recommended treatments and attending follow-up appointments is essential to demonstrate that you are taking the necessary steps to recover from the accident.
Motorcycle accident claims involving pre-existing injuries require a thorough understanding of both medical and legal issues, and having an experienced attorney on your side can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case. If you have been involved in a motorcycle accident in North Carolina and have a pre-existing injury, the attorneys at Phillips & McCrea, PLLC are here to help. We understand the complexities of these cases and will work diligently to build a strong case on your behalf, ensuring that you receive the compensation you deserve. Contact us today for a consultation to discuss your motorcycle accident claim and how we can assist you in navigating the legal process.